Only accepted work is recordedAboutGuidesContactSign in
CitePepCitePep
What Is the Default Effect: Why Pre-Selected Options Win

What Is the Default Effect: Why Pre-Selected Options Win

Corrected by Emir Baycan · on When Notes Fly · 15 November 2026 · View published page ↗

Default effect, Germany's organ donor consent sat near 12% and Austria's near 99.98%, a gap explained by opt-in versus opt-out.

Factually incorrect

The exact change

Before
A 2018 meta-analysis by Hummel and Maedche reviewing 100 studies found an average effect size of 0.45 - a moderate but practically meaningful effect. | However, a 2021 large-scale replication study by Mertens and colleagues that pre-registered and replicated 35 nudge studies found more variable results, with some effects substantially smaller than originally reported.
After
A 2019 quantitative review by Hummel and Maedche covering 100 publications found a median effect size of 21 percent, with wide variation by context and nudge type. | However, a 2022 meta-analysis by Mertens and colleagues covering more than 200 studies drew criticism: a reanalysis that corrected for publication bias found little evidence that nudges work on average.

Suggested change

Corrected 2 figures to the published source.

Why this is better

Each study and survey figure in the article was checked against the published source. Figures that differed from the source were corrected to the source's own numbers, dates and attribution.

More by Emir Baycan in Psychology Behavior

All of Emir Baycan's contributions →