Only accepted work is recordedAboutGuidesContactSign in
CitePepCitePep
Cobra Effect in Education: When Incentives Backfire

Cobra Effect in Education: When Incentives Backfire

Corrected by Emir Baycan · on When Notes Fly · 15 November 2026 · View published page ↗

The cobra effect in education: high stakes testing produced the Atlanta scandal, with erased answer sheets found in 44 of 56 schools.

Factually incorrectNeeds stronger evidence

The exact change

Before
The exchange was efficient from an accountability standpoint and potentially damaging from the standpoint of civic education. | A 2017 review by Darling-Hammond and colleagues found that sustained professional development programs (typically 40+ hours over a school year) produced effect sizes averaging 0.54 on student achievement, substantially larger than any financial incentive study has found.
After
Removed. | A 2017 review by Darling-Hammond and colleagues identified 35 rigorous studies in which professional development improved both teaching practice and student outcomes, and found that sustained duration was one of the features effective programs shared.

Suggested change

Corrected 1 figure to the published source. Removed 1 unsourced claim.

Why this is better

Each study and survey figure in the article was checked against the published source. Figures that differed from the source were corrected to the source's own numbers, dates and attribution. Claims for which no published source could be located were removed.

More by Emir Baycan in Learning Science Knowledge

All of Emir Baycan's contributions →